Challenging Perspectives in Storytelling
The innovative storytelling approach known as the change-of-perspective standalone episode has emerged as a unique method to showcase detailed short narratives within broader series, illuminating the diverse viewpoints and experiences of secondary characters.
In an ideal scenario, Apple TV+’s “The Big Cigar” would have been an episode spun from a larger tapestry detailing the Black Panthers’ history, offering a closer look at figures such as Huey P. Newton, Bobby Seale, and Eldridge Cleaver. Only after setting that comprehensive history could the series pivot to spotlight an unexpected tale originally residing on the fringes of these iconic stories.
A Narrative Split
“The Big Cigar” attempts to simultaneously tell the tale of Newton as a fugitive and the misadventures of well-intentioned but misguided white Hollywood producers. The show grapples with merging a historic chapter of the Black Panthers with the lighter, escapade-driven narration of the producers, leading to a bifurcated story where neither theme is fully explored.
Set in 1974, the series follows a disenchanted Newton (André Holland), who seeks help from film producer Bert Schneider (Alessandro Nivola) while on the run from the law. In a scheme reminiscent of “Argo,” Newton is to be secreted away to Cuba under the pretense of a faux movie project, eluding the one-dimensional FBI pursuers.
Although the early episodes directed by Don Cheadle showcase a visually engaging style, the tone and aesthetic grow inconsistent as the series progresses. It gleans from similar works but fails to maintain its unique identity.
Past and Present Collide
The series struggles to capture the essence of Newton primarily due to the constant shifts between various timeframes and the underlying reluctance to dive into deeper, controversial aspects of his life. The show also fails to utilize key figures in the Black Panther movement, favoring historical reiterations instead of original portrayals. Despite these issues, “The Big Cigar” does reflect certain realities, dedicating moments to Newton’s charisma and the once vibrant Black Panther party, albeit inconsistently.
Facts Not Mentioned but Relevant:
– The Black Panther Party was a political organization founded in 1966 by Huey P. Newton and Bobby Seale to challenge police brutality against the African American community. They also ran social programs such as free breakfast for children and community health clinics.
– Bert Schneider was a real film producer known for bankrolling critical and controversial films during the 1960s and 1970s, such as “Easy Rider” and “Five Easy Pieces.”
– The “Argo” reference pertains to the covert operation and 2012 film directed by and starring Ben Affleck, where a fake movie production was used as a cover to rescue American hostages from Iran.
– Huey P. Newton was a controversial figure with a multifaceted legacy, including his scholarly work doctoral dissertation, which was adapted into his book “War Against the Panthers.”
Key Questions and Answers:
– What challenges does the series “The Big Cigar” face in storytelling?
The main challenge comes from attempting to blend the serious political history of the Black Panther Party with the more light-hearted Hollywood antics. Balancing the solemnity of Newton’s plight with the comical elements of the producers’ misadventures could potentially undermine the significance of both storylines.
– What controversies are associated with “The Big Cigar”?
The potential controversy lies in the oversimplification of the Black Panther movement and Newton’s life, the possibility of marginalizing profound struggles for comedic effect, and the dilemma of faithfully representing historical figures and events without alienating viewers seeking entertainment.
– What are the advantages and disadvantages of “The Big Cigar’s” storytelling approach?
Advantages: This unconventional narrative tactic could attract a wider audience, bring more attention to lesser-known histories, and create an engaging blend of thriller and comedy.
Disadvantages: It risks trivializing important historical events, potentially through incoherence or disrespecting the legacies of those involved. It also may struggle to portray the complexity of real-life events and maintain a consistent tone.
For additional information on the Black Panther Party or film producer Bert Schneider, which could provide further context to the series, here are two links to explore:
– NAACP: Check this site for an understanding of civil rights movements and organizations related to the Black Panthers.
– The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences: For insights on Bert Schneider’s influential role in Hollywood and the kind of films that could have inspired “The Big Cigar.”
The source of the article is from the blog maestropasta.cz